#2 We improv- Round 1 - Printable Version

#2 We improv- Round 1 - Printable Version

+- Tony Hawk Pro Skater 3 (http://www.chapter-3.net/thps3/v2)
+-- Forum: Competitions (/forumdisplay.php?fid=184)
+--- Forum: Tournaments (/forumdisplay.php?fid=186)
+---- Forum: Archive (/forumdisplay.php?fid=246)
+----- Forum: Improv tours (/forumdisplay.php?fid=240)
+------ Forum: We Improv (/forumdisplay.php?fid=275)
+------ Thread: #2 We improv- Round 1 (/showthread.php?tid=4010)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8

RE: #2 We improv- Round 1 - Giel - 06-02-2015 16:15

Can the judges post all their ratings?

RE: #2 We improv- Round 1 - Shizz - 06-02-2015 16:28

(06-02-2015 16:15)Giel Wrote: Can the judges post all their ratings?

Furthermore , since I am not selected for next round, I should now have the right to rage as Dav would do Laugh

Just kidding, I was expecting it. It's the first time that I really started doing improv tho, but I'm sure I'm not the only one. Therefore I also like to know my rating and maybe some points of criticism or just someone that tells me how I mainly can become better. What I did wrong or what I forgot to do.

And it may sound weird that I'm saying this but shin thanks for putting your effort in organising this, also because it was really annoying (for you and everyone) with the unreachable/untrustable players. I just hope more competitions will get organised in future because I never (or not much) really participated in one in the past and after all this is the best way to get better in this game!

RE: #2 We improv- Round 1 - Lyst - 06-02-2015 16:45

Maker:
Style 6.5
Level usage 7.5
Flow 6.5
Total: 20.5

Giel:
Style: 5.5
Level usage: 7
Flow: 7.5
Total: 20

Gston:
Style: 6
Level usage: 7.5
Flow: 8
Total: 21.5 + 0.5 for finishing on the lamp = 22

Jailoco:
Style: 6.5
Level usage: 6
Flow 7
Total: 19:5

Prohad:
Style: 7.5
Level usage: 6.5
Flow: 5.5
Total: 19.5

1. Gston 22
2. Maker 20.5
3. Giel 20
4. Jailoco 19.5
4. Prohad 19.5

Group B
Shizz:
Style 5.5
Improv 6.5
Flow 5.5
Total: 17.5

Faith:
Style 6.5
Improv 7.5
Flow 6.5
Total: 20.5

Pluto:
Style: 5.5
Improv: 6.5
Flow: 7.5
Total: 19.5

Rev:
Style: 6.5
Improv: 6
Flow: 7.5
Total: 20

Blooming:
Style: 4.5
Improv: 6.5
Flow: 5
Total: 16

Ranking:
1. Faith 20.5
2. Rev 20
3. Pluto 19.5
4. Shizz 17.5
5. Blooming 16

Kaoz
Style: 5.5
Improv: 6
Flow: 6.5
Total: 18

Kush:
Style: 6.5
Improv: 5.5
Flow: 7
Total: 19

Pinky:
Style: 7
Improv 6.5
Flow: 6
Total: 19.5

Natan:
Style: 6.5
Improv: 7
Flow: 7
Total: 20.5

Tronic:
Style: 6
Improv: 5.5
Flow: 5.5
Total: 17

Ranking:
1. Natan 20.5
2. Pinky 19.5
3. Kush 19
4. Kaoz 18
5. Tronic 17

And for fun:
Wild:
Style: 6.5
Improv: 6.5
Flow: 6
Total: 19

Ownish:
Style: 7.5
Improv: 7
Flow: 8
Total: 22.5

Ranking
1. Ownish 22.5
2. Wild 19

RE: #2 We improv- Round 1 - shin - 06-02-2015 18:07

well. Lyst and Blue used this system that Lyst posted. I just watched the videos and judged it from the best to the worst video in my opinion.

Now I will explan how i counted the points.

For example Lyst's judgement:
Ranking:
1. Faith 20.5
2. Rev 20
3. Pluto 19.5
4. Shizz 17.5
5. Blooming 1

so Faith got 5 points, Rev 4 points, Pluto 3 points, Shizz 2 points, Blooming 1 point

I made the same with Blue's and my judgements.

So if I gave 4 points to Faith and Blue 4 so Faith got 13 points overall. That's how I created a ranking and 3 players with best scores advanced to 2nd round.

Anyway I don't need to explain my decisions and watch the videos again to make it clear. I tried to watch the videos carefully, sometimes a few times to judge whose run was better or worse.

If you really wanna know something about some provs then PM me. Explain me why you disagree with the scores and I will tell you my point of view.

PS. Thx shizz Wink

Good luck to you next time Wink

RE: #2 We improv- Round 1 - Faith - 06-02-2015 18:33

alright. yeah i was just wondering about jailloco and prohad. cus i was so anoyed by the 1000 wrap arounds which where spinned in the wrong direction. but i agree his flow was better P: thnx for the post lyst

RE: #2 We improv- Round 1 - KaOz - 06-02-2015 20:16

very well judged. I knew it would be eliminated in the first round

GG all
and i need a second opportunity Surrender

(playoff)

good luck all

RE: #2 We improv- Round 1 - bluey - 06-02-2015 21:13

need my notes? Original

RE: #2 We improv- Round 1 - shin - 06-03-2015 09:37

(06-02-2015 21:13)bluey Wrote: need my notes?

RE: #2 We improv- Round 1 - wild786 - 06-03-2015 15:24

when im judge i just use my gut feeling haha

RE: #2 We improv- Round 1 - Lyst - 06-03-2015 18:55

I only watch every vid once, so I don't get biased. Grading the different elements and adding them later, makes it easier to remember each video. And because I do not rank on names, it's less likely I have some preferences for certain players.